1. Introduction to Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore
When it comes to high-quality interior and exterior paints, two names stand out in the U.S. market: Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore. Both brands have built strong reputations for durability, color selection, and performance. But how do they compare? Before diving into paint finishes, lets take a closer look at the history and presence of these industry leaders.
Sherwin-Williams: A Legacy of Innovation
Founded in 1866, Sherwin-Williams has grown into one of the largest paint manufacturers in North America. Known for its extensive network of retail stores and strong presence in both residential and commercial markets, Sherwin-Williams offers a wide range of products catering to homeowners, contractors, and designers alike.
Key Features of Sherwin-Williams:
- Over 4,000 company-owned stores across the U.S.
- A strong focus on innovation with proprietary technologies like Emerald® and Duration® paints
- Extensive partnerships with professionals in construction and design
- A broad selection of colors backed by digital tools like ColorSnap®
Benjamin Moore: Premium Paints with a Designer Touch
Established in 1883, Benjamin Moore is known for its commitment to quality and premium formulations. Unlike Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore distributes its products through independently owned retailers rather than company-owned stores. This approach allows customers to receive more personalized service while still accessing top-tier paint products.
Key Features of Benjamin Moore:
- A trusted brand among designers and homeowners seeking high-end finishes
- Exclusive color technology, including the highly regarded Aura® line
- Sold primarily through independent retailers for specialized customer service
- A reputation for rich pigments and excellent coverage
Comparing Market Presence
While both brands dominate the U.S. paint industry, they cater to slightly different audiences. Sherwin-Williams has a broader reach due to its widespread store locations and contractor-friendly approach. On the other hand, Benjamin Moore appeals more to homeowners and designers looking for premium quality with a boutique shopping experience.
| Feature | Sherwin-Williams | Benjamin Moore |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 1866 | 1883 |
| Main Distribution Method | Company-owned stores | Independent retailers |
| Best Known For | Durability & professional-grade paints | Rich pigments & designer-preferred colors |
| Popular Product Lines | Emerald®, Duration®, SuperPaint® | Aura®, Regal Select®, Ben® |
| Target Audience | Contractors, builders, DIYers | Homeowners, designers, boutique shoppers |
| Color Selection Tools | ColorSnap® Visualizer App | Pint-sized color samples & fan decks |
| Retail Locations in U.S. | 4,000+ | Mainly sold through local independent dealers |
The Foundation for Comparing Paint Finishes
Now that we have a better understanding of these two leading brands, we can dive deeper into their paint finishes. Whether youre looking for a matte or high-gloss finish, both Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore offer a variety of options tailored to different needs. In the next section, well explore how their finishes compare in terms of durability, application ease, and aesthetic appeal.
2. Types of Paint Finishes Offered
When choosing the right paint for your project, its important to understand the different finishes available. Both Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore offer a variety of paint sheens, each with its own characteristics and best uses.
Comparison of Paint Finishes
Heres a breakdown of the most common paint finishes provided by Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore:
| Finish | Appearance | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Matte | Flat, non-reflective | Ceilings, low-traffic areas, bedrooms |
| Eggshell | Slight sheen, smooth finish | Living rooms, dining rooms, moderate-traffic areas |
| Satin | Soft sheen, more washable than eggshell | Kitchens, bathrooms, hallways |
| Semi-Gloss | Sleek shine, highly durable | Molding, trim, doors, high-moisture areas |
| High-Gloss | Very shiny, reflective surface | Cabinets, furniture, accent pieces |
The Differences Between Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore Finishes
Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore both offer these finishes, but their formulations vary slightly. Sherwin-Williams paints are often known for their durability and washability, making them a great choice for high-traffic areas. On the other hand, Benjamin Moore is praised for its rich pigmentation and smooth application.
Sherwin-Williams Paint Finishes Overview
- Easier to clean: Their satin and semi-gloss finishes tend to be more scrubbable.
- Bolder colors: Some users find Sherwin-Williams paints provide more vibrant color options.
- Larger selection in professional-grade paints: Many contractors prefer Sherwin-Williams for commercial projects.
Benjamin Moore Paint Finishes Overview
- Smoother application: Their matte and eggshell finishes have a softer texture.
- Pigment-rich formulas: Provides deeper coverage with fewer coats.
- Aesthetic appeal: Many designers recommend Benjamin Moore for its luxurious finish.
Your choice between Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore will depend on your priorities—whether you need something highly durable or a finish that offers a premium aesthetic. Understanding how each finish performs will help you make an informed decision for your space.
3. Durability and Performance
When choosing paint, durability and performance are key factors, especially for high-traffic areas or moisture-prone spaces like kitchens and bathrooms. Both Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore offer high-quality finishes designed to withstand wear, but their characteristics differ slightly.
Durability in High-Traffic Areas
Walls in busy areas like hallways, living rooms, and kids rooms require a durable finish that can resist scuffs, stains, and frequent cleaning. Here’s how both brands compare:
| Brand | Best Finish for High-Traffic Areas | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| Sherwin-Williams | Emerald® Satin / Duration® Matte | Highly durable, stain-resistant, easy to clean |
| Benjamin Moore | Aura® Matte / Regal Select® Eggshell | Scuff-resistant, excellent washability, long-lasting color |
Performance in Moisture-Prone Spaces
Kitchens and bathrooms demand paints that resist moisture, mildew, and frequent scrubbing. Both brands have options specifically formulated for these environments:
| Brand | Best Finish for Moisture-Prone Areas | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| Sherwin-Williams | DURATION® Home Satin / Emerald® Urethane Trim Enamel | Mildew-resistant, moisture-repellent, durable finish |
| Benjamin Moore | Aura® Bath & Spa Matte / ADVANCE® Satin | Mold-resistant technology, superior adhesion in humid conditions |
Sherwin-Williams vs. Benjamin Moore: Which One Performs Better?
The choice between Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore depends on your specific needs. Sherwin-Williams is known for its advanced stain-blocking properties and durability in high-traffic areas. Meanwhile, Benjamin Moore offers exceptional washability with long-lasting color retention. If youre painting a bathroom or kitchen, Benjamin Moores Aura Bath & Spa is a great option due to its mold-resistant formula, while Sherwin-Williams’ Duration Home provides strong moisture resistance.
The Bottom Line on Durability and Performance
If you need a tough paint that stands up to daily wear and tear, both brands provide excellent options. However, the best choice will depend on your space’s unique requirements—whether it’s preventing scuffs in a hallway or combating humidity in a bathroom.
4. Cost and Value
When choosing between Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore, cost plays a major role for homeowners, contractors, and designers. While both brands offer high-quality paint, their pricing structures and value can differ significantly.
Price Comparison
Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore both have a range of products at different price points. Here’s a general breakdown:
| Brand | Entry-Level Paint (Per Gallon) | Mid-Range Paint (Per Gallon) | Premium Paint (Per Gallon) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sherwin-Williams | $45 – $60 | $65 – $85 | $90 – $120 |
| Benjamin Moore | $40 – $55 | $60 – $80 | $85 – $110 |
Coverall and Efficiency
The amount of coverage per gallon varies by product line, but generally, both brands offer excellent coverage with fewer coats required for premium paints.
| Brand | Coverall Per Gallon | No. of Coats Needed (Typical) |
|---|---|---|
| Sherwin-Williams | Around 350-400 sq. ft. | 1-2 coats |
| Benjamin Moore | Around 350-400 sq. ft. | 1-2 coats |
The Value Proposition for Homeowners, Contractors, and Designers
The best choice depends on the user:
– Homeowners:
If youre painting a single room or refreshing your home, Benjamin Moore’s mid-range options often provide great coverage at a slightly lower price. However, if you’re looking for long-lasting durability, Sherwin-Williams’ premium lines may be worth the investment.
– Contractors:
Sherwin-Williams offers bulk discounts and contractor accounts, making it an attractive option for professionals working on multiple projects. Their accessibility through dedicated stores also makes purchasing more convenient.
– Designers:
If color accuracy is a top priority, Benjamin Moore’s extensive color selection and consistency make it a favorite among designers. Its high-end finishes also provide a sophisticated look that appeals to luxury projects.
No matter which brand you choose, evaluating the balance between cost and performance is key in making the right decision for your specific needs.
5. Application and Ease of Use
When choosing between Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore, one key factor to consider is how easy each brands paint is to apply. Factors such as coverage, drying time, and the number of coats required can make a big difference in your painting experience.
Coverage Comparison
Both Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore offer high-quality paints with excellent coverage, but there are some differences. Sherwin-Williams paints tend to have a thicker consistency, which can help with one-coat coverage on lighter colors. Benjamin Moore paints, particularly the Aura line, also provide great coverage but may require an extra coat for deep or bold colors.
| Brand | Coverage Per Gallon | One-Coat Coverage? |
|---|---|---|
| Sherwin-Williams | 250-400 sq. ft. | Yes, for lighter colors |
| Benjamin Moore | 350-400 sq. ft. | Yes, but deep colors may need two coats |
Drying Time
The drying time of paint affects how quickly you can apply a second coat or finish your project. Sherwin-Williams paints generally dry within 1-2 hours before recoating, while Benjamin Moore paints may take slightly longer at around 2-4 hours depending on humidity levels and ventilation.
| Brand | Touch Dry Time | Recoat Time |
|---|---|---|
| Sherwin-Williams | 1 hour | 1-2 hours |
| Benjamin Moore | 1-2 hours | 2-4 hours |
Number of Coats Required
The number of coats needed depends on the type of finish and color youre using. In general, both brands recommend two coats for optimal durability and evenness, but premium lines like Sherwin-Williams Emerald and Benjamin Moore Aura often provide full coverage in just one coat when applied correctly.
| Brand | Recommended Number of Coats | Painters Experience Level Needed |
|---|---|---|
| Sherwin-Williams (Emerald) | 1-2 coats | User-friendly, even for beginners |
| Sherwin-Williams (Duration) | 2 coats recommended for best results | User-friendly but requires even application |
| Benjamin Moore (Aura) | 1 coat for most colors, 2 for deep tones | Easier for experienced painters due to fast drying time |
| Benjamin Moore (Regal Select) | 2 coats recommended for best results | User-friendly for DIYers and pros alike |
User-Friendly Application for DIYers vs. Professionals
If youre a DIYer looking for an easy-to-use paint, Sherwin-Williams Duration and Benjamin Moore Regal Select are great options as they offer smooth application with minimal brush or roller marks. Professionals who want quick-drying options with superior coverage may prefer Benjamin Moore Aura or Sherwin-Williams Emerald.
Sherwin-Williams Pros & Cons:
- Pros: Thicker consistency provides better coverage; dries faster; good adhesion to various surfaces.
- Cons: Can be harder to work with if you’re not experienced; requires proper technique to avoid streaks.
Benjamin Moore Pros & Cons:
- Pros: Smooth application; great durability; self-leveling formula reduces visible brush strokes.
- Cons:: Slightly longer drying time; premium lines can be expensive.
No matter which brand you choose, proper preparation—such as priming when necessary and using high-quality brushes or rollers—will help ensure the best results.
6. Final Verdict: Which Brand Should You Choose?
When deciding between Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore, it ultimately comes down to your specific needs. Both brands offer high-quality paint with various finishes, but certain factors like durability, aesthetics, and budget can help guide your choice.
Durability and Performance
If you need a highly durable paint that withstands wear and tear, Sherwin-Williams is often the better option. Many of their products, such as Duration and Emerald, are known for their excellent durability, making them great for high-traffic areas.
Benjamin Moore also offers durable options like Aura and Regal Select, which provide long-lasting coverage. However, Sherwin-Williams tends to have slightly better resistance to scuffs and stains.
Aesthetic Preferences
If achieving a premium look is your priority, Benjamin Moore is often preferred by designers due to its rich pigmentation and smooth application. Their color selection is vast, and their finishes tend to provide a more refined appearance.
Sherwin-Williams also offers beautiful colors and finishes, but some users feel that Benjamin Moore paints provide a more elegant final result.
Budget Considerations
Your budget plays a crucial role in choosing between these two brands. Here’s a general price comparison:
| Factor | Sherwin-Williams | Benjamin Moore |
|---|---|---|
| Average Cost per Gallon | $45 – $70 | $50 – $75 |
| Premium Paint Lines | $60 – $100+ | $65 – $100+ |
| Availability of Discounts | Frequent sales & contractor discounts | Fewer promotions, but loyalty discounts available |
The Best Choice for Your Needs
- If you want the most durable option: Sherwin-Williams higher-end paints may be the best choice for high-traffic areas.
- If you prioritize color richness and aesthetics: Benjamin Moores pigments and finish quality may suit you better.
- If budget is your biggest concern: Sherwin-Williams offers more frequent discounts that could make it the more affordable option.
- If youre hiring a professional: Many contractors prefer Sherwin-Williams due to their availability and pricing flexibility.
- If youre doing a DIY project: Benjamin Moores ease of application might make it the better choice for homeowners painting on their own.
No matter which brand you choose, both Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore offer excellent paint finishes that can enhance any space. Consider your priorities, whether its durability, appearance, or cost-effectiveness, to find the best fit for your project.
